by C.L. Halvorson
The cottage door slammed open, wrenched from the old man’s hand by a ravenous wind. Coats hanging behind it barely muffled the resulting crash, and several fell to the floor in empty heaps.
With shoulders hunched against the cold, the old man hurried across the threshold. One hand clutched a wicker basket to his chest; the other failed to stop the wind from snatching his hat and sending it skittering across the floor. The man took hold of the door and wrestled it closed. He threw his entire weight against it until, finally, it settled into the jamb.
A sort of quiet descended, the whipping wind muffled by thick doors and sturdy walls. The fire hadn’t yet gone out in the fireplace. Its embers glowed warmth into the open space.
Heaving a satisfied sigh, the old man crossed to the table and set the basket down, peeking inside to check its contents were safe. Pleased, the man removed his coat, picked up his hat, and hung them both on their pegs behind the door. Then he opened the basket once again to admire what was inside.
Buttery, flaky crust. Red filling oozing from the vents. Braided decorations along its outer edge. Still steaming, ever so slightly, carrying the scent of tart and sweet with just the slightest hint of almond and citrus. He breathed in deeply and sighed. The widow made the best pies, and cherry had always been his favorite.
Not for the first time, the old man wondered if he should court the widow. She was not quite his age, but certainly close enough to be respectable. They could live a good life together, and he’d get to eat pies like this every night.
But that was a thought for another time.
The old man left the pie to rest in its basket and began preparing his evening meal. Though he was not a wealthy man, he had been successful enough in work and investments to live quite comfortably, with a full larder and a few niceties. Tonight he had a slab of veal, crumbly cheese, crisp greens, crackly bread, herbed butter, and a good red wine, all bought fresh from the market that morning, before the winds turned sour. It was a little self-indulgent, but then again, it was his birthday.
The old man uncorked the bottle and poured himself a glass. He sipped it as he cooked, savoring the taste and texture of the wine on his tongue, the smell and sizzle of cooking meat.
Finally, at long last – dinner, prepared and plated. Juices oozed from the veal, cooked quite rare, just as he liked. Butter slathered over the bread, spotted with flakes of chive and rosemary. The greens, slightly wilted and sprinkled with lemon juice. He rose his glass to the mirror and smiled at his reflection. “Happy birthday to you, sir,” he said. Then, napkin tucked into his collar, knife and fork in hand, he descended on his plate.
Knock.
Knock.
Knock.
How strange. The wind still whistled outside, and it must be even colder now than when he’d come home. Who could possibly be wandering about now?
The old man stood, folded his napkin on the table and, with a hint of sheepish greed, tucked the pie out of sight. Then he went to the door and opened it a crack, struggling against the wind, and peeked into the night.
A short, wide, hunched figure stood on his stoop. An old woman, swathed and bundled in layers of cloaks and rags. She peered up at him from behind her sagging hood and straggling hair. “Please, sir,” she asked with a shaking voice. “I’m so hungry.”
“Good heavens, dear woman!” the man exclaimed. “Come in at once.”
She did, murmuring thank you’s as the old man braced the door against the wind. As soon as she was inside he bullied it closed and turned back to his guest.
“Now then, dear – what on earth are you doing wandering around on your own like this?”
Her eyes were bright and dark as she peered back at him. “Have to wander,” she answered. “I’m so hungry.”
She stood before him, stooped under a tailor’s worth of stained cloth, face etched with wrinkles and scrunched with need. The man’s heart ached for her, this dear old thing, with no business being outside alone on a night like this.
“Well, here,” he said. “Come sit down, and you can share my dinner with me. Shall I take your cloak?”
“No, no, I think you shan’t.”
“Of course.”
She smelled strange, he noticed. Not bad, exactly. There was just a certain pungence about her, and a certain chill. She smelled like spices and frost.
“Would you like me to build the fire up?” he asked. “It’s freezing out tonight.”
“I don’t know,” she said, head bowed as she shuffled toward the table. “I’m so hungry.”
“Of course,” he repeated. “My apologies.” He took his plate to the kitchen, found another, and divided his dinner between them. After a moment’s thought, he cut the veal into bite-sized pieces too. She seemed a little shaky. This should be easier for her.
“Here we are, my dear.” He set her plate in front of her before pouring her a glass of wine and sitting down himself. “You know, it’s my birthday today,” he told her. “It’s nice to have some company.”
The old woman did not reply, only watched him with those shining eyes. Her teeth, he noticed, looked very strong for her age. So did her hands. He smiled at her, though it was a bit hesitant this time. “Please, enjoy.”
The words were hardly out of his mouth before she started to eat.
She ignored the silverware he had laid out for her. Greens were scooped up and swallowed in two fistfuls. Meat was tossed between gnashing teeth. Buttered bread soaked up every drop of juices before disappearing down her gullet.
It was rude to stare, the old man knew it, but he couldn’t help himself. He had never seen anyone eat so ravenously.
She looked at him, licking her lips as she did so. “Are you still hungry?” he asked.
She nodded.
The old man meant to get some cheese and rye from the larder. Instead he pushed his own plate across the table. He still hadn’t taken a single bite.
It was as if she hadn’t eaten anything at all. The rest of his dinner, gone in minutes. He half expected her to lick the plates.
“Are – do you feel better?” the old man asked, as the old woman sucked on her fingers and stared. She shook her head.
“I am hungry, so very hungry.”
So he went to the larder.
Cold cuts. Dried fruits. Preserves. Crackers. Sausages. Vegetables. He gathered armfuls at a time and brought them to the table. She devoured it all. The old man couldn’t believe his eyes, couldn’t understand how it was possible. No one could be this hungry. No one could take this much.
The old man wanted to put a stop to it, to tell her that she couldn’t possibly eat any more, that he couldn’t afford to give away all this food – that he wanted to help her but this was just not reasonable. He felt the words on his tongue, but his mouth stayed shut.
Because she was hungry.
So very hungry.
At long last, but far too soon, there was nothing left in the larder. She had cleaned it out, or rather, he had cleaned it out for her, and she had eaten it all. “Please,” she said, grasping at his shirt, hands too strong and teeth too white. “I’m hungry.”
There was only one thing left.
So he retrieved his pie, set it in front of her. He stood, transfixed, as she plunged down a hand and scooped out its center. Flakes of crust and chunks of filling dropped from her hand and fell from her mouth as she gulped it down, staining her face and fingers with red. It oozed from between her teeth when she smiled at him, crimson on grinding white.
The pie was gone, eaten from the inside out. The old woman did lick the dish this time, leaving it sparkling clean.
She must be satisfied now. There was no possible way she couldn’t be.
The old woman sat at his table, the ruins of her impossible feast surrounding her – crumbs, wrappings, and empty plates. There was nothing left.
The old man looked down at her. She looked up at him. She reached out one red-stained hand.
“Please,” she said. “I’m so hungry.”
“But you’ve already eaten everything I have!”
This he tried to say. Instead, he gave her his hand. She brought it to her mouth.
—
Crunch.
Crunch.
Crunch.
—
The young mother sank into her chair, weariness aching in her bones. Another long day in a lifetime of long days, hands chafed from the work of them all, but for a moment she had a chance to rest. The children were fed and asleep, for now. The chores were done for the night. She’d have to go to bed soon, but first, finally, dinner.
She pulled her abandoned plate towards her. It was cold, of course. She rarely had a chance to eat a meal while it was still hot, the children and housework keeping her too busy to spare a moment to sit down. There wasn’t much anyway – limp roasted vegetables and stale bread. It was the best she could do right now.
Three knocks pierced the quiet of the night, and the young mother hurried to the door, fearing the sound would wake her little ones. She opened the door a crack. Frigid wind blasted inside, and she shivered as she peeked out.
“Can I help you?”
The huddled creature on her doorstep nodded, eyes dark as they looked up at her. Her face, the young mother thought, reminded her of the little dolls she made for her children, with heads made from dried and shrunken apples. It was ancient and inscrutable, and she felt a terrible unease settle on her shoulders.
“Please,” the old woman said. She was wringing her hands in front of her – wrinkled, wiry hands, fingernails hooked and sharp. “Please,” she repeated, looking up at the young mother, gaze imploring. “I’m so hungry.”
featured on KLAW Halloween 2026

Leave a Reply